Now what?

A mishmash of thoughts on religion, life, technology, and whatnot.

Happy Armistice Day

My grandfather served in WWII under Gen. Hodges in Patton’s army. He didn’t talk about it. He never wore camouflage again, or military green, and I don’t think he ever fired a gun again either. I think it pretty much scarred him for life. I don’t think it’s easy to understand what being in a war is like. You can’t understand it from watching the news, there are movies, and books, and documentaries that help you understand it a little better, but without going through it, I don’t know how we’ll ever truly understand the hell on earth that is war.

We glorify it. I admit, I enjoy playing shoot-em-up games. I love Call of Duty and other WWII games. I enjoy the history of it. But I’m sure that we can only have those kinds of games because we have some distance from them. I’m sure it’ll be only a matter of time before there’s a first-person shooter where you have to escape from the World Trade Center before it collapses, or you have to try to kill the terrorist before he crashes into the towers. I’ll give it 10-15 years.

My dad tells stories of my grandfather’s survival reflex kicking in during 4th of July celebrations. When he’d hear a loud noise, he would hit the deck immediately.

Recently, a couple of shows have given me a greater understanding of what he might have gone through. Tom Hank’s HBO series Band of Brothers is based on real people and real events. There are episodes in it that give you a brief glimpse into the psychological toll of the war. And the recent PBS mini-series The War also gives you first-hand reports from those who were there. Telling stories on film that you probably couldn’t tell in polite company 40 or even 20 years ago.

Our veterans have been put through hell in our name. We should honor their sacrifice and service by staying out of unnecessary wars, thus my use of the original name of today’s holiday. WWII came about out of the disastrous policy decisions after WWI. Nothing happens in a vacuum.

I’ll admit that I was suckered in by the Bush Administration in the lead-up to the Iraq War. I have an admiration for those who weren’t. They were right. I get emails forwarded to me talking about the good things we’re doing in Iraq, how many policemen they have now, how many hospitals we’re building. Truth is, even though they were under the despotic Hussein, they had more police and order and schools and hospitals before we showed up. Sure their lives weren’t great, but were it not for their oil, we wouldn’t be there. People don’t like to believe it, but it’s the truth. War is good for the state, and we are a warlike people. “No,” you say, “we’re a peaceful people.” How do you explain this then? At the height of the Roman Empire, the Romans had an estimated 37 major military bases scattered around their dominions. At the height of the British Empire, the British had 36 of them planetwide. Depending on just who you listen to and how you count, we have hundreds of bases. According to Pentagon records, in fact, there are 761 active military “sites” abroad. [HT: Tom Engelhardt]

World War II didn’t start in a vacuum either.

Controversial, but interesting nonetheless: Thanks for the Freedom, Vets.

Excerpt: In America, we enjoy the freedom of giving half our income to the government through various forms of taxes. We have the freedom to participate in a Ponzi scheme known as Social Security. We have the freedom to vote for the president. Unlike the voters of Iraq under Saddam Hussein, who only had one choice for president, we have two choices!

On the subject of our next scheduled war in Iran: Documents linking Iran to nuclear weapons push may have been fabricated. C’mon…they wouldn’t do that, would they?

“The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.” — H.L. Mencken

Activity

2 total comments, leave your comment or trackback.
  1. Good read, as always. I agree with most of it (as always). Whenever I think about the subject of Iran/Iraq/whatever-war-we-’re-in-or-could-be-in … my mind sometimes drifts to this …

    “As explained in Goldstein’s book, the Ministry of Peace revolves around the principle of perpetual war. If the citizens of Oceania have a well-defined enemy, Eastasia or Eurasia, then they know whom they hate, and constant homeland propaganda helps to convince them to vent all their unconscious rage for their own country against the opposing one. Since that means the balance of the country rests in the war, the Ministry of Peace is in charge of fighting the war (mostly centered around Africa and India), but making sure to never tip the scales, in case the war should become one-sided. Oceanic telescreens usually broadcast news reports about how Oceania is continuously winning every battle it fights, though these reports have little to no credibility.

    As with all the other Nineteen Eighty-Four ministries, the Ministry of Peace is named the exact opposite of what it does, since the Ministry of Peace is in charge of maintaining a state of war.”

    (copied from Wikipedia: search = Ministry of Peace)

    Simply more fodder.
    Ben

  2. Thanks for sharing this. My maternal grandfather also served in Patton’s army and never recovered psychologically from the experience. I believe we owe it to our armed forces to learn as much as we can about national security, foreign policy and our armed services so that we can make decisions as informed citizens when we send our military into harm’s way. Blindly supporting any American military intervention isn’t patriotic.

    The best thing we can do now is to make sure our veterans are getting help for PTSD and reintegrating back into civilian life. Our failure to do this has been a national sin.


Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word